5 replies to this topic

[Lewis]

This controversy often sparks heated arguments to say the least. Moreover, there have also been instances of fights, vandalism and worse over which is the best. Windows users claim that Mac users are arrogant, citing that old "computer for the rest of us" advertising while Mac users claim the same about Windows users. Who really cares?

The truth of the matter is that both are about the same. All they are, are different GUIs; slightly different ways of opening applications. Once the application is open, the only differences might be whether you use a single button mouse or a multi-button mouse, and even that difference vanishes with third party hardware.

First of all, we'll look at some pros and cons for each, then we'll dispel some myths perpetuated about both platforms. We'll also see how this plays into which might be better suited for Web design.

Remember, also, that both Microsoft and Apple share a good deal of technology. Both Windows and MacOS use hundreds of patents shared between the two. Also remember that Microsoft makes a lot of software for the Mac including Microsoft Office which was created by a separate department for the Mac.

Typography - Mac's support of typography is a result of years and years involvement with the pre-press industry. Type-styles rendered with a Mac just plain transfer better when submitted to a service bureau. You get what you saw. If you're into pre-press Mac is the clear winner here.

Video Subsystem - Windows open architecture and PCI bus allow a wide non-saturated video subsystem. Video cards are made which exceed 6 Gigaflops of geometric rendering. Mac, though PCI, has a severely bottle-necked video subsystem so if you're into advanced 3-D rendering, Windows is the clear winner here.

Postscript Support - Mac natively supports both postscipt and PDF formats making them the clear winning here. Again, if you're into pre-press, Mac makes a lot of sense.

Back to Resources Raw Speed - Windows PCs have a serious edge here. Where time is money, processor speed can be very important. Regardless of how hard Mac advertising attempts to claim that the slower clock speed Macs are really just as fast as a PC, it just ain't so and proven so by every bench test out there. If you have the "need for speed" in gaming, software development, 3D rendering and other applications, Windows is the clear winner here.

Color Matching - Apple is the only OS and hardware which supports Colorsync™, the industry standard for "what you see is what you get" color matching. If you want your advertising copy of an egg to come out of the press with the same yellow you saw on the screen, Mac is for you.



Web Design - Now this will be a hot one. In my opinion the clear choice here is Windows. I say this for two reasons.

* First, 95% of the people surfing the Web use Windows on PCs. If you want to be able to design in an atmosphere where you see pretty much what that 95% sees, then Windows just plain makes sense.
* Secondly, though many technologies are available for the Mac, Windows technology isn't and much of the Web uses this technology. If you want to take advantage of .NET technology or ASP, it's just way easier to implement from a Windows platform.


Ease of Use - I give Mac the edge here, though the difference is pretty small with the release of Windows XP. Windows binary Plug-in-Play is no longer "Plug-n-Pray" and though technologically superior to Mac doesn't get the job done as nicely. By using nearly draconian messures and monopolistic threats, Apple has been able to maintain tight control over makers of third party hardware. What this means to you is an easier to use system, but with much less choice in add-ons.

Back to Resources

Software Availability - Though many might argue that anything you might need is available for Mac, and though almost all generic task software is, industry specific software is not. For example, if you own.. say a lawnmower repair shop, you might want software written exclusively to run lawn mower repair shops. You just won't find it on the shelf or by mail order for the Mac, while you have several to choose from for Windows, maybe even for free or cheap as shareware downloads.

You might argue that you can adapt database and spreadsheet software to need, but it's just not as easy. Advantage to Windows.

Coolness Factor - What can I say? Mac wins. Look at that new i-Mac or the i-Pod. It beats a biege box.

Geek Factor (I'm one) - Windows wins (Linux beats that and BSD might beat Linux)

[Man'n'Black-4xp]

Quote

Back to Resources Raw Speed - Windows PCs have a serious edge here. Where time is money, processor speed can be very important. Regardless of how hard Mac advertising attempts to claim that the slower clock speed Macs are really just as fast as a PC, it just ain't so and proven so by every bench test out there. If you have the "need for speed" in gaming, software development, 3D rendering and other applications, Windows is the clear winner here....

No questions about it , even my ancient Dell running ancient XP Ican run more apps at once, longer, harder.

Quote

The truth of the matter is that both are about the same. All they are, are different GUIs; slightly different ways of opening applications. Once the application is open, the only differences might be whether you use a single button mouse or a multi-button mouse, and even that difference vanishes with third party hardware.

Wrong-o!
You want pretty you want MAC\Apple
You want brute strentgh...linux
you want power and ease of use Windows

[Man'n'Black-4xp]

Sometime I think we do away with GUI entirely...

[jram]

I'm talking laptops here, that's all I use.. Two different test.. The first is 2 different laptops with more or less the same specs. http://www.laptopmag...-windows-7.aspx

This one is on the same laptop, just swapping drives.









Just to add, there is a lot more to a OS than games and 3 D rendering, using my browser I can watch all of Youtube and most movie sites with a Quicktime pop out, what this means is I can make the screen any size I want and take the screen with me, not being stuck on the site I'm watching.. When i download the movie, it is MP4, say the movie is 700 MB, for me it's 230 MB or 240MB, with just as good picture quality or better, plus downloading is twice as fast if not faster. Even here on this site it's QT, I can make the screen as big or small as I want.



Do this with XP

[Man'n'Black-4xp]

Not sure I understand what you are bragging about, but I can resize QuickTime, I can display multiple QuickTime boxes {or screens or whatever}...
What I can't do is HEAR multiple audio soures, just a jumbled mess of sound...

[jram]

I'm not bragging about anything, what I'm saying is when any youtube video is on this site it doesn't show up as Flash, it shows up as QT.. When you see a Flash video you can't resize the video to any size you want to. That in itself isn't a big deal , but on most sites I go to watch a online movie like Megavideo , Loombo etc etc I can do this.. It makes for a pleasant viewing when you watch a 2 hour on line movie. We weren't talking about this anyway, you said a PC is better then a Mac in anything, the link and graphs says your wrong. This goes double for that old relic XP